You ask a question. Nobody answers. Twelve faces look back at you from their little boxes, and three more are black squares with a name in the corner. Are they thinking? Are they lost? Are they answering emails? In a room, you’d know within seconds. Online, you often have no idea.
That’s the real challenge of engagement in online workshops. It isn’t that people engage less online (some people engage more), it’s that the signals you rely on in a room mostly disappear. The nods, the shuffling, the side conversations and the moment someone leans forward are all either flattened into a small video tile or switched off entirely.
Video calls are tiring in their own particular way, too. Stanford’s Jeremy Bailenson has suggested four reasons why: unnaturally close eye contact, the extra effort it takes to send and read signals on screen, constantly seeing your own face, and sitting still for much longer than we would in a room.1 They’re ideas rather than proven causes, but anyone who’s spent a day on video calls will recognise them.
So you have to stop waiting for engagement signals and start designing them in. In this article, I’ll cover what engagement actually looks like online, the signals worth watching, eight practical ways to check in as you go (starting with the humble pulse check), and how to measure engagement afterwards without turning your workshop into a surveillance operation.
What engagement actually looks like online
Before you can monitor engagement, it helps to be clear about what you’re looking for. I find it useful to think about three kinds:
- Doing: people are taking part in what you asked them to do: typing in the chat, answering polls, adding sticky notes to the whiteboard, talking in breakout rooms.
- Feeling: people are interested and have some energy for the topic. This is the hardest to see online, and the easiest to guess wrongly.
- Thinking: people are wrestling with the ideas. Their contributions build on each other, they ask real questions and they disagree with you (politely, ideally).
The trap is to measure only the first kind, because it’s the easiest to count. A chat full of ‘great point!’ and thumbs-up emojis looks busy, but it doesn’t tell you much. Ten thoughtful contributions from a quiet group can be worth more than fifty reactions.
And please don’t treat cameras as an engagement meter. A camera that’s on tells you that a camera is on. Some of the most engaged people in my sessions keep theirs off, because they’re sharing a room, feeding a baby, managing a long-term health condition or simply concentrate better without looking at their own face.
There’s research to back this up. In a 2021 field study of 103 employees, Kristen Shockley and colleagues found that having cameras on made people more tired, and that tiredness made them less engaged in meetings.2 The effect was stronger for women and for people who were newer to the organisation. Insisting on cameras can backfire.
Signals worth watching during the session
No single signal tells you much on its own. Look for patterns and changes, and treat each one as a question rather than a verdict.
| Signal | What it might mean | What to try |
|---|---|---|
| The chat goes quiet after being busy | People are tired, lost or busy with something else | Run a quick pulse check, or change the activity |
| The same three people answer every question | Others are unsure, or the questions are too open | Ask everyone to answer in the chat at the same time |
| Poll responses drop or arrive slowly | Attention is drifting, or the poll is confusing | Keep polls to one simple question and say how long they have |
| Cameras switch off mid-session | Fatigue, a break needed, or a busy home | Take a short break; don’t comment on individuals |
| Breakout rooms come back with nothing | The task was unclear, or too long or too short | Give written instructions and a shared doc for each room |
| Lots of chatter in the chat | Usually good news: people are engaged with each other | Let it run, and pick up the best points out loud |
Eight ways to check engagement as you go
1. Run a pulse check
A pulse check is a quick, structured way to ask the whole group how they’re doing, without anyone having to make a speech. Ask a simple question and give people a scale to answer on, then look at the spread.
“On a scale of one to five, how clear is this so far? Pop your number in the chat, but don’t press enter until I say go.”
Holding back the answers until you say ‘go’ (a chat waterfall, see below) stops people copying the first answer. You could also use a poll, the platform’s reaction buttons, or ask people to hold up fingers on camera. In a room, or on camera, you could use Fist to Five, where people hold up between zero and five fingers on a count of three.3 Other versions I like include a weather report (‘Are you sunny, cloudy or stormy right now?’) and an energy check (‘Battery level: what percentage are you on?’).
The pulse check is only useful if you act on it. If most people say two out of five, don’t carry on regardless. Slow down, ask what’s unclear, or take a break.
2. Use quick polls
Polls give everyone a voice in a few seconds, including people who’d never unmute. Keep them short, with one question and a handful of options, and show the results so people can see where the group sits. A well-placed poll every 15 to 20 minutes also gives you a running record of how many people are still responding.
3. Try a chat waterfall
Ask a question, ask everyone to type their answer without pressing enter, then count down and let everyone send at once. The answers cascade down the chat, nobody is influenced by the first reply, and you get a clear sense of who’s with you. It works brilliantly for check-ins, quick reflections and testing understanding.4
4. Make reactions part of the session
Most platforms have reaction and feedback buttons: thumbs up, raised hand, and in some cases ‘yes’, ‘no’, ‘go slower’ or ‘go faster’. They’re only useful if people know they’re allowed to use them. Spend 30 seconds at the start showing people where the buttons are and inviting them to use ‘slower’ whenever they need to.
5. Drop into breakout rooms
Breakout rooms are where a lot of the real engagement happens, and where you can’t see it. Give each room a shared document or whiteboard frame to work in, so you can watch the work grow from the main room. If you drop in, say who you are, keep your camera on, and don’t take over: you’re there to listen and to check that the task makes sense.
6. Ask for a contribution little and often
A rule of thumb many online facilitators use is to give everyone something to do every few minutes: answer a poll, type in the chat, add a sticky note or talk in pairs. Training providers suggest anything from every three to five minutes to every ten, and none of it is based on firm research, so the exact number matters less than the habit. (And no, people don’t have an eight-second attention span. That claim has been debunked, even though a 2021 survey by King’s College London found that half of UK adults believed it.5) If you’ve been talking for 15 minutes without asking anyone to do anything, you’ve given people permission to drift.
7. Bring in a producer
It’s very hard to present, watch the chat, manage breakout rooms and read the mood all at once. A producer or co-facilitator can track the chat, notice who hasn’t contributed, spot technical problems and quietly tell you when energy is dipping. For anything longer than an hour, or with more than about 15 people, I think it’s worth it.
8. Take proper breaks
Sometimes the best response to flagging engagement isn’t a clever activity, it’s a break. In a small 2021 study, Microsoft’s Human Factors Lab measured people’s brain activity during back-to-back video meetings and found that stress built up over two hours without a pause. Short breaks between meetings reset it.6 In a long online workshop, plan a proper screen break at least every hour, and take one early if your pulse checks tell you to.
How to measure engagement afterwards
What happens in the session is only part of the story. To know whether your workshop actually worked, look at a few things afterwards. If you know the Kirkpatrick Model for evaluating training, you’ll recognise its four levels in this list: reaction, learning, behaviour and results.7
- Attendance and drop-off: most platforms produce an attendance report showing who joined, when and for how long. A steady drop after the break or at a particular activity is worth investigating. Depending on your licence, Microsoft Teams attendance reports can also show reactions, raised hands and cameras turned on,8 and Zoom can produce reports of poll answers and questions asked.9
- Participation: count poll responses, chat contributions and whiteboard additions, and look at how they change across the session. Look for trends, not individual scores.
- Reaction: a short feedback question at the end, such as an Exit Ticket, a 3-2-1 Reflection or the Evaluation Thermometer, tells you how the session felt to the people in it.
- Learning: a quick quiz, a practical task or asking people to explain an idea in their own words shows whether the content landed.
- What happens next: a follow-up a few weeks later, asking what people have used or changed, is the most meaningful measure of all, and the one most often skipped. If the workshop was meant to change something in the organisation, check whether it did.
Monitor engagement, don’t monitor people
There’s a line between checking how a group is doing and watching individuals, and it matters. Your aim is to adjust your workshop, not to grade the participants. Zoom learned this the hard way: it permanently removed its ‘attendee attention tracker’ in April 2020, after concerns about privacy.
- Be open about what you collect: if you’re recording the session or using attendance and participation reports, tell people at the start and explain why.
- Report on the group, not individuals: share participation trends, not a league table of who said what. If a manager asks for individual engagement scores, push back.
- Don’t insist on cameras: invite them, explain why they help, and accept that some people will keep them off.
- Be wary of tools that claim to read emotions or attention: the ICO’s guidance on monitoring workers warns that video monitoring can be highly intrusive and that emotional analysis raises the risks further.10 In the EU, AI that infers people’s emotions in workplaces and education has been banned since February 2025. These tools tend to measure the wrong thing anyway. I’ve written more about this in Can an AI Avatar Replace a Workshop Facilitator?
A simple engagement plan for your next online workshop
- Open with a quick check-in that everyone answers, such as a chat waterfall or a One-Word Check-Out in reverse: one word for how you are arriving.
- Show people where the reaction buttons and chat are, and invite them to use them.
- Plan something for people to do every few minutes, and mark the pulse checks in your session plan.
- Give breakout rooms written instructions and a shared space to work in.
- Ask a producer to watch the chat and tell you when energy dips.
- Close with a short reflection and a feedback question.
- Look at the attendance and participation patterns afterwards, and follow up a few weeks later.
Online engagement doesn’t happen by accident, but it doesn’t need fancy tools either. Design in small moments for people to take part, keep checking in, and act on what you hear. Your group will tell you how they’re doing, as long as you give them the means to.
How do you measure engagement in an online workshop?
During the session, watch participation in polls, chat, reactions and breakout rooms, and use pulse checks to ask people directly. Afterwards, look at attendance and drop-off, participation trends, end-of-session feedback, what people learned, and whether they’ve used it a few weeks later.
What is a pulse check in a workshop?
A pulse check is a quick question that the whole group answers at once, usually on a simple scale, such as ‘How clear is this, from one to five?’. It shows how the group is doing in a few seconds, so you can slow down, change activity or take a break.
Should participants have their cameras on?
Invite cameras rather than insisting on them. Research has found that keeping cameras on can make people more tired, which in turn lowers engagement, and many people have good reasons to keep theirs off. Judge engagement by what people contribute, not by whether their camera is on.
How often should you interact with participants online?
There’s no fixed rule, but many facilitators aim to give people something to do every few minutes, such as answering a poll, typing in the chat or talking in pairs. If you’ve been talking for more than ten or fifteen minutes, it’s time to involve the group.
Sources
- Bailenson, J. (2021): Nonverbal Overload: A Theoretical Argument for the Causes of Zoom Fatigue. Technology, Mind, and Behavior. ↩︎
- University of Georgia: Cameras, not meetings, cause Zoom fatigue. A summary of Shockley and colleagues’ 2021 study in the Journal of Applied Psychology. ↩︎
- CASEL: Fist to Five. ↩︎
- SessionLab: Chat Waterfall. ↩︎
- King’s College London (2022): Are attention spans really collapsing? ↩︎
- Microsoft Work Trend Index (2021): Research proves your brain needs breaks. ↩︎
- Kirkpatrick Partners: The Kirkpatrick Model. ↩︎
- Microsoft Support: Manage meeting attendance reports in Microsoft Teams. ↩︎
- Zoom Support: Conducting polls in meetings. ↩︎
- Information Commissioner’s Office: Data protection considerations for different ways of monitoring workers. ↩︎


